Pages

Showing posts with label Homeplug. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Homeplug. Show all posts

Friday, 19 April 2013

Review: TP-Link AV500+ Gigabit Powerline Adapter

TP-Link has been quite busy recently, especially on the Homeplug front. I recently reviewed its new AV500 Nano Homeplug adapters for Computeractive magazine (unfortunately the review is not available online), and now I've had a chance to look at the larger AV500+ 'piggyback' adapters (model number is TL-PA551KIT for the twin starter pack).

Design and features

Unlike many bland Homeplug adapters, at least the PA551 has a touch of style, with a distinctive black body and white fascia panel. The passthrough mains socket is at the top of the fascia, with three green/orange status lights below. The build quality is excellent, with a solid feel to the adapters. In the box is the quick installation guide, mini-CD with the software utility and manual, plus two Ethernet cables.

Unlike the AV500 Nano adapters, the PA551 has a Gigabit Ethernet port, which gives them a decent - but not massive - performance advantage. The adapters are pretty bulky, though, being the same width but longer than the previous AV200 version (PA251). They won't fit side-by-side in a ganged extension socket, which in some ways is no bad thing - using them in extension sockets is never a good idea as it can affect performance if the extension has a surge suppressor.

The small Powerline utility is quite basic, but tells you links speeds and allows QoS settings to be changed, either using simple application settings (Internet, Games, Audio/Video or VoIP), or more complex VLAN or  TOS bits.

Quite stylish for a Homeplug adapter

The utility lets you set QoS parameters and upgrade firmware

Performance

I used my standard test setup (see this post for more details), and used the latest version (1.3) of Totusoft's LAN Speed Test, with LST Server on the remote PC to check the throughput. The adapters pair up very quickly when plugged in - something that some adapters seem to take ages to do. Using the default packet size of 1MB and 100 test iterations, the results stack up pretty well compared to other AV500 adapters I've tested.

Average write speeds were 124Mbps, and read speeds 125Mbps, which is about the same as other AV500 models I've seen. It also means that the Gigabit Ethernet ports do give a 25% improvement over the AV500 Nano adapters, which are limited to 100Mbps. Out of interest, I also ran tests with a pair of older PA251 AV200 adapters - these managed around 70Mbps read and write throughput.

So you do get a lot of benefit out of moving to the AV500 standard, but you should never expect full 500Mbps speeds - that only refers to the PHY link speed, not throughput. According to the software utility, link speeds were around 350Mbps on the PA551 during testing - they wouldn't connect any higher. Variability during test runs wasn't too bad, either, at around 5-10%.

Verdict

At a street price of around £80, the PA551 twin-pack is cheaper than the Devolo dLAN 500 AVPlus and speeds are comparable. They do look more attractive than most other models, but they are large. The passthrough mains socket is ideal for those with a limited number of wall sockets, though. This product should definitely be on your shortlist if you're looking for some reasonably-priced, well-made Homeplug adapters.

Details
Model: TP-Link TL-PA551KIT AV500+ Gigabit Powerline Adapter
Cost: £79
Contact : TP-Link


Find it on Amazon:


Friday, 25 May 2012

Review: Netgear Powerline Nano500 set (XAVB5101)

For some reason, it's been a busy time for new Homeplug products. Netgear's latest offering is a miniature 500Mbps model based, as usual, on the Qualcomm Atheros AR7400 chipset. The nicest thing about these adapters, apart from their excellent performance and very useful software utiliity, is their incredibly compact size. They are no wider than most standard UK plugs, making them easy to plug in anywhere. You can read my full review over on ITProPortal, and see performance results compared to some other models on my recent review of the similarly-priced Devolo dLan 500 AVMini adapters.

The adapters are a perfect fit in a double mains socket


The optional utility software lets you turn off the adapter LEDS


Find it on Amazon:


Thursday, 24 May 2012

Review: Devolo dLan 500 AVMini Starter Kit

I've had a bit of a Homeplug-fest recently, with several companies releasing new 500Mbps products at the same time. The latest is Devolo's 500 AVMini Starter Kit, which contains two miniature siblings of the 500 AVPlus models I reviewed recently.



Miniature adapters seem to be the latest craze, and it's understandable if you've ever tried to plug a full-size adapter into a UK double wall socket - in many cases, they just won't fit alongside a standard mains plug. The odd thing about the 500 AVMinis is that they are 65mm wide, which is exactly the same as the huge 500 AVPlus adapter. Every other dimension is smaller, however - the thickness (excluding the plug) is 30mm versus 40mm, and the length 80mm rather than 130mm. As with the 500 AVPlus, this means that they are a very tight fit in a double socket.

In the box you get a pair of decent quality network cables (not snagless ones, though), plus a quick-install guide and a CD with the excellent dLan Cockpit utility software.

They share the same styling as most of Devolo's adapters, featuring a well-ventilated white casing with a Gigabit Ethernet port at the base and a reset/encryption button next to it. The three status LEDs on the top face are large and easy to read, showing red, orange or green to indicate the Homeplug connection speed. They will work with 200Mbps Homeplug AV adapters, but not with Homeplug 1.0 devices (they will coexist happily, but won't be able to talk to each other).

The dLan Cockpit software (see picture below) allows users to add adapters using the security code printed on the adapter, view the link speeds between Devolo adapters (other brands won't show up), rest or change the passwords and give them descriptive names. There's also a basic troubleshooting guide.

Technology

As far as I am aware, all 500Mbps Homeplug devices, including the 500 AVMini and AVPlus, are based on the Qualcomm Atheros AR7400 series of chips. Although complying with the Homeplug AV standard for 200Mbps connectivity, they use a wider frequency range of 2-68MHz (instead of 2-28MHz) to achieve higher throughput when they detect other AR7400-based devices. They also incorporate a Gigabit Ethernet port instead of the mandated 10/100Mbps port in the standard. This will all change when products based on the long-awaited Homeplug AV2 standard appear, with support for gigabit link speeds (note that any products you see at the moment described as 'Homeplug AV2' are certainly not, as some retailers incorrectly use this tag to describe 500Mbps Atheros-based products).

Performance tests

I have standardised on Totusoft's excellent LAN Speed Test and LST Server for testing powerline devices. It's simple, quick and reliable, and as I'm not particularly interested in graphing throughput for these devices it works fine (I still use Passmark for NAS and Wifi testing, however, due to its graphing features).

My high-tech testbed
For the test setup, I've found by trial and error that the most reliable way to get maximum repeatable performance is to plug two adapters into each end of an extension socket, which is then connected to a dedicated mains socket. This arrangement removes most of the effects of my rubbish domestic wiring, and usually allows me to get the full advertised link speeds. I also do informal tests using random sockets around the house, but the results vary so much that they are not really useful to anyone who doesn't live in my house. With the AVMinis, I found that on most occasions I could easily get 150-200Mbps link speeds even in the worst cases (as indicated in the dLan Cockpit software), giving performance up to about half of the maximum.

Dlan Cockpit showing the 500Mbps link speed before testing

As I tested the 500 AVMinis, I realised that as I had a decent collection of powerline adapters (Devolo, Netgear and Solwise) lying around, I might as well test them all together to give a performance matrix for future reference. The results are shown in the table below. All adapters were upgraded to the latest firmware versions I could find. The figures shown are the average of the read and write performance results, averaged over three test runs using a 1MB packet size (the default) with a 100-packet test duration. This extended duration helps even out the initial ramp-up in throughput often seen with these adapters.

Homeplug performance results - top 10 results highlighted in red

As you can see, the 500 AVMinis did very well, tieing with the 500AVPlus for top performance between identical adapters. Perhaps unsurprisingly, they also worked well with the Netgear AV5101 Atheros-based adapters, although a fraction slower than when working with another 500AVMini. These speeds make them much more attractive than the 200Mbps models. Unfortunately I only had a single Devolo 200 AVMini, so I couldn't get a result for that cell.

The Solwise adapters are an oddity, being based on the 1Gbps Gigle MediaXtream chipset. This claims to work with Homeplug AV, and it does, but not particularly well. When the Solwise adapters appeared, their performance was impressive, but they now appear to have been overtaken by Homeplug.

Conclusion

The Devolo 500 AVMini Starter Kit is the joint fastest Homeplug adapter I've tested, tying with the Devolo 500 AVPlus to give real throughput of up to 135Mbps in ideal conditions. The adapters are small, but no narrower than the 500 AVPlus model, making them still quite a tight fit if you want to use them in a dual wall socket. The software is excellent (although it's not needed for operation), and the kit is a similar price to the competing Netgear XAVB101 kit (a full review of this is coming shortly), but if you want maximum performance they are highly recommended.

Details
Model: Devolo dLan 500 AVMini Starter Kit 
Price: £100 inc VAT
Manufacturer's website: www.devolo.co.uk



 Find it on Amazon:


Monday, 27 February 2012

Review: Devolo dLAN 500 AVplus Starter Kit

Many Homeplug manufacturers are now offering devices conforming to the 500Mbps AV+ standard, and Devolo is no exception. These 'piggyback' adapters (with a passthrough mains socket) are quite chunky but do a pretty good job, as you can see in my full review over on Computeractive.

The dLAN 500 AVplus has a handy passthrough mains socket
The Cockpit software is very useful for checking link quality

Find it on Amazon:

Tuesday, 18 October 2011

Review: Solwise PL-500AV-4PE 4-port Homeplug switch

Homeplug is all very well when you can't use Wifi or wired Ethernet, but if you have to buy an adapter for each piece of kit it can get expensive. This Solwise 4-port Homeplug 500AV switch is a great solution. Read my full review on IT Reviews.





Find it on Amazon:


Friday, 13 May 2011

Review: Devolo dLAN 200 AV USB Extender

USB over IP seems like a pretty logical use for powerline networking, so it's a little surprising that it's taken so long for an adapter to appear. Devolo's handy Homeplug AV-certified gadget lets you share any kind of USB device over a network, even scanners and multifunction devices, and it works extremely well. All you have to do is install the Devolo USB device driver on each PC. Read my full reviews of it on IT Reviews and Computeractive.




Find it on Amazon:

Tuesday, 15 March 2011

Review: Netgear XAVB5001 Powerline AV 500 kit

It took Netgear an awful long time to release the UK version of these 500Mbps powerline adapters, but they have now finally appeared. They use an Atheros AR7400 chip that employs a broader frequency range than standard Homeplug AV kit. They are excellent devices, and you can read my full reviews, including performance results, on IT Reviews, The Inquirer and Computeractive.




Find it on Amazon:

Tuesday, 5 October 2010

Review: Solwise Mediaxtream PL1000

My review of the Solwise Gigabit powerline adapters has now been published by Computeractive. As I noted earlier, Solwise reported that the original models had a power supply fault that has now been fixed. Replacement units have been sent free of charge to all the original customers.






Wednesday, 1 September 2010

Review: Solwise 1000Mbps Mediaxtream / Homeplug AV adapters

My review of these new high-speed powerline adapters from East Yorkshire-based Solwise has just been published on The Inquirer. They are powered by a Gigle Networks GGL541 chip, the same one used in Belkin's Powerline HD product. I've also done a news summary comparing these with Netgear's new 500Mbps Powerline AV 500 models for ZDnet UK.



UPDATE 18/9/2010: Solwise has informed me that a problem was discovered with the power supplies in the original batch of these adapters, causing them to reboot spontaneously under noisy mains conditions. Solwise has rectified the fault and free replacements have been shipped to all existing customers. I'll be looking at a pair of the new ones over the next couple of weeks to see if there's any change in performance.

UPDATE 16/2/11: I finally got round to testing the updated version of this adapter, and the results were very interesting, leading me to believe that perhaps there was more to the problem in the firmware than just random rebooting.

Recreating as far as possible the conditions in the original test, I installed a pair of the adapters on a single 4-way extension lead with no other devices plugged in. Using Passmark's Advanced Network test, the average transfer rate between the two shot up to a staggering 130Mbps/sec (in my original tests, they managed just 94Mbps). As you can see from the graph below, this average was reduced by the early negotiation phase, and after this they were sustaining around 136Mbps. Even when putting the adapters on two widely separated extension leads containing lots of other devices, the rate only dropped to around 95-100Mbps. 

A very positive result for Solwise, and it makes these adapters the fastest I've seen. And at just £86 for a pair, they're pretty good value too. At the moment, I'm testing the Netgear XAV5001 500Mbps devices, and I'll post a link to my reviews when they're done. But I can say that they do work with the Solwise adapters.