Another bargain from TP-Link, for those who don't need 3-stream 11n capabilities
Router prices are dropping to crazy levels, typified by
the measly £60 you need to get hold of the TP-Link TL-WDR3600. This is a
dual-band, dual-stream (N600) cable model (it doesn’t have an ADSL modem), and although it offers little in the way of innovation it has plenty of decent features and adequate performance.
 |
| It's not pretty, but it works well |
 |
| Dual USB2 ports distinguish this from the WDR3500 |
Hardware
The design is exactly the same as the pug-ugly
TL-WDR4300 (click for my review),
with a large, shiny black plastic case that - to my mind at least - just makes
it look cheap and nasty. This feeling is reinforced by the 10 (yes, 10) blue
status LEDs on the front. Blue LEDs have been so overdone in recent years that
now they just look old-fashioned. In this case, it’s not helped by the fact
that the LEDs are quite large and most of them blink constantly, which is
incredibly distracting if the router’s in view. I do like status LEDs, but they
need to be both discrete and clear - in the WDR3600 it’s hard to tell which is
which from a distance, and they don’t change colour when there’s a problem,
just blink differently.
It has two standard detachable dual-band external antennas.
These look a bit ungainly, but many users still prefer them to the more
fashionable internal micro-antennas. At the back are the standard four Gigabit
Ethernet ports, plus a dedicated WAN port (also Gigabit Ethernet). Two USB2
ports (which differentiate this model from the single-ported WDR3500), a power switch and reset button complete the external hardware features.
Configuration
Styling aside, there’s plenty to like about the WDR3600. The
setup wizard on the CD works well, and allows you to clone the MAC address if
needed. There’s also a wizard in the web management menu, which can be opened
using the http://tplinklogin.net shortcut (the default username and password
are both ‘admin’).
The settings menu is the standard TP-Link 3-column
text-based interface (there’s an emulator at
http://www.tp-link.com/resources/simulator/TL-WDR3600/Index.htm
if you want to take a look). There’s a growing trend to graphical interfaces,
but I still prefer the speed and simplicity of text, as long as stuff is easy
to find. In this case, it is, with a category menu down the left side, settings
in the middle and contextual help at the right.
The USB ports support printers and storage, but not 3G
dongles. User accounts can be created for volume-level access via Windows
Explorer, but shared folders can only be created for FTP access.
There’s also a DLNA media server, although this can only
share up to six separate folders on each storage device.
 |
| It uses the standard TP-Link menu layout |
One unusual feature, also seen in the WDR4300, is the
hardware NAT acceleration - this can be enabled or disabled in the NAT section
of the settings. Personally, I think it’s a bit of a waste of time - all it
does is improve WAN to LAN throughput to a quoted 800Mbps. This feature is
really intended for enterprise use when connected to a Gigabit WAN, so that
internet traffic can be sent at wire speed. For ordinary broadband, it’s not really
necessary. Also, some readers of this blog have complained about the hardware
NAT affecting VoIP in the WDR4300, although during a couple of weeks’ testing the
WDR3600 I saw no problems (my SIP provider is Sipgate).
Access Control
The WDR3600 does have a few access control features,
including parental controls and bandwidth control. They’re not the easiest for
novices to set up, though, as they do need an understanding of protocols and
ports. The parental controls can be used for white-/blacklisting IP addresses,
domains or protocols and scheduling access times for any MAC address. Bandwidth
control is fairly basic, allowing rules-based limiting of inbound or outbound
traffic. There are no automated QoS settings.
Interior
The WDR3600 is powered by Atheros chips, with an AR9344
system-on-a-chip (SoC) providing the 2.4GHZ radio, plus a separate AR9582 2x2 chip
for 5GHz operation. An AR8327 chip provides the Gigabit Ethernet switching.
This hardware is very similar to that found in its big brother, the TL-WDR4300,
with the exception of the 5GHz radio - the WDR4300 uses a 3x3 AR9582 chip.
The WDR3600 is configured by default for auto channel width
settings on both bands. As usual, I tested using the defaults. My test
environment (my home) is surrounded by several neighbouring 2.4GHz networks
(but no 5GHz networks yet), making it a good place to see real world performance.
As usual, I used the Advanced Networking Tests section in Passmark
Performance Test 8 (I do also run Totusoft’s LAN Speed Test for a quick sanity check).
The standard client adapter I use is a 3-stream (450Mbps) Intel Ultimate N Wifi
Link 5300AGN adapter retrofitted to an Acer Aspire One netbook.
At close range (1m) on the 2.4GHZ band the WDR3600 did very
well compared to some routers I’ve seen recently, managing 50Mbps average
throughput. It didn’t do so well at 25m, though, with a very unreliable
connection averaging around 5Mbps.
At 5GHz the close range performance was actually slightly
less than the 2.4GHz results at 48Mbps, which is quite unusual. However, at 25m
it was much better at 18Mbps - this is still a fairly average result, however.
 |
| 1m/2.4GHz |
 |
| 1m/5GHz |
 |
| 25m/2.4GHz |
 |
| 25m/5GHz |
Conclusion
Although its performance results are not particularly
noteworthy, considering the price they’re perfectly acceptable. Oddly, the
numbers are slightly better than those I measured in the more expensive TL-WDR4300.
It does have an almost identical set of features to the
WDR4300, though, and given that the WDR3600 is around £15-£20 cheaper, I’d definitely
recommend it, especially for those who don’t have any 3-stream 11n clients.
Price: around £60
Contact details
Phone: +44 (0) 845
147 0017
Find it on Amazon:
